The Michigan High School Athletic Association (MHSAA) should significantly reduce tumbling skills in competitive cheerleading scoring.
Michigan's competitive cheerleading format consists of three distinct rounds, each with specific scoring. Round one is based on the execution of jumps and synchronized motions. Round two focuses on team unity and also incorporates tumbling elements. Round three focuses difficulty of stunt sequences alongside team tumbling performances. This structure means that tumbling skills directly impact scoring in two of the three competitive rounds, creating a high risk injury rate.
This heavy scoring on tumbling presents serious concerns for attention. The fundamental issue lies in the dangerous conditions under which these athletes must perform. Cheerleaders are required to execute complicated tumbling passes on what are commonly referred to as "dead mats". But, gymnasts train and compete on specialized equipment designed specifically for tumbling, including spring floors and high-quality mats that significantly reduce impact forces.
The current system forces athletes to attempt increasingly dangerous tumbling sequences, including standing skills and running passes that place stress on their bodies. Medical professionals have these safety concerns. Orthopedic surgeons report treating numerous cheerleaders for injuries directly related to performing tumbling skills on dead mats. While coaches and officials often emphasize the importance of "proper technique," the reality is that even perfect execution cannot mitigate the risks associated with equipment. When something does go wrong, and in such a high-risk environment, injuries and their consequences can be severe and potentially permanent.
This system creates a situation where young athletes must choose between their long-term health and achieving their competitive goals. High school cheerleaders should not risk their physical well-being. Tumbling transforms what should be an empowering and skill-building experience into a dangerous one with potentially life-altering consequences.
The solution requires the MHSAA to fundamentally reconsider its scoring priorities, reducing the influence of tumbling while elevating other cheerleading skills that can be performed safely. By making this change, the organization would demonstrate its commitment to athlete safety while preserving the competitive and unique character of Michigan cheerleading.
